Broadband spectrum for mission critical communication needed
The TETRA and Critical Communications Association (TCCA) is the sector association representing the interests of over 160 public and private users, operators and manufacturers of mission critical communication services, hardware and software.
EU member states, in cooperation with the Commission, are in preparation for the ITU World Radiocommunications Conference 2015 to identify a single spectrum environment for Broadband Public Protection and Disaster Relief (PPDR) services and to define conditions for taking the 700 MHz band to mobile use, including conditions for PPDR use of the band. TCCA recommends that a sufficient amount of 700 MHz frequency resources shall be made available for these mission critical communication services.
What is mission critical communication?
Mission critical communication is supplied by special communications systems where the reliability, availability, stability and security of mobile communication is vital to ensure continuous availability of functions critical for society. Typical users of mission critical communication are law enforcement and emergency services for public protection and disaster relief (PPDR) operations. Mission critical communications include communication hardware, software, as well as radio frequency band (spectrum) capacity to transmit and share information between field units and command centres.
Current status of public safety mobile communication
Traditionally, emergency services throughout Europe use a part of 380-400 MHz spectrum for voice communications. This frequency band allows today for effective mission critical voice communications, whilst the needs for mission critical broadband data communication cannot be covered until such time that a suitable amount of radio frequency spectrum has been identified under harmonised conditions in Europe.
Emergency services have an increasing demand for access to mobile broadband data services for their PPDR operations. The establishment of mission critical mobile broadband data services requires a frequency band located below 1 GHz. An opportunity is opening at 700 MHz. This band is today inter alia used by terrestrial broadcasting services, but is expected to be re-allocated to mobile service at the World Radiocommunications Conference in Nov. 2015 (WRC-15).
The immediate beneficiaries are likely to be private mobile operators who offer commercial mobile broadband services to the public. However, a specific agenda item of the WRC-15 is dedicated to the agreement of a Resolution, which adds one or more frequency bands for mobile broadband PPDR services throughout Europe, Middle East and Africa. It is of the utmost importance for the European PPDR community that a European Common Position on this agenda item incorporates the 700 MHz band for Broadband PPDR.
The PPDR community, through the EU Council’s Law Enforcement Working Party (LEWP) has worked jointly with the spectrum regulator community (CEPT-ECC) and concluded in an ECC Report that a minimum of 2 x 10 MHz spectrum is required for mobile Broadband data services, with additional spectrum required to implement voice services, Air Ground Air, Direct Mode Operation and ad hoc networks.
What is the problem?
The available frequencies are limited and in high demand, and Member States are reviewing how these can be used most efficiently. The biggest challenge arises from the PPDR organisations' stated need for dedicated frequency bands and the spectrum regulators' obligation to satisfy both PPDR requirements and the commercial demand for more spectrum. Currently a few options are under discussion, and each of these has either operational shortcomings or economic consequences:
1. The organisations responsible for PPDR are convinced that their needs for mission critical broadband services can only be met by dedicated harmonised spectrum. Regardless of whether communication services are delivered by a government or a commercial operator, it is essential for governments to keep control of an adequate amount of radio spectrum under EU harmonised conditions in order for their PPDR organisations to deliver a future proof service to society.
2. It is evident that spectrum regulators in some countries plan to auction all available 700 MHz bandwidth to the highest commercial bidder. In such cases, Emergency Services will be forced to purchase capacity from a commercial cellular network operator. They will have to share capacity with business and the general public, even during major incidents where life and property are at stake. Experience shows that commercial operators are unable to guarantee the availability, security and stability of communications especially during times when good communications are needed most.
How can these shortcomings be addressed?
TCCA advocates that whenever a Member State decides to implement a PPDR broadband service – whether by building a dedicated network, as required by its emergency services, or by outsourcing to a commercial operator, or a combination – it must be implemented within a PPDR spectrum range agreed within CEPT that permits seamless operation of broadband PPDR equipment across borders in Europe, where such systems have been implemented. Such position should be reflected in the European Common Position for WRC15.
Request to the EU institutions
EU Member States are individual members of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) whilst the European Commission holds an observer status with no voting rights even though representing the European Union. Both the Commission and CEPT have emphasised that public order and public security are matters of national competence of the Member States.
However, the Schengen Acquis and the Community Mechanism for Civil Protection are examples of instruments that enhance community co-operation; furthermore it is in the public interest to have seamless cross-border communications for all emergency services in the EU. TCCA therefore believes that the EU institutions should play a guiding role in the allocation process of 700 MHz spectrum across the European Union to ensure free movement of emergency services and to safeguard the provisions of the single market for PPDR equipment and services.
In particular, European institutions should ensure that PPDR is allocated sufficient 700 MHz spectrum and that data communication solutions are interoperable across the EU. In fact, we encourage all responsible Directorate Generals of the Commission to take further actions to implement the provisions of the Radio Spectrum Policy Programme (RSPP) Article 8.31
What should happen next?
Discussions are currently taking place within and between Member States on the future use of 700 MHz frequencies and future Broadband PPDR services, with the aim of presenting a coordinated position of all EU and CEPT Member States at the World Radiocommunication Conference (WRC-15) in November 2015, organised by the International Telecommunication Union (ITU-R).
We request that action is taken to ensure that RSPP Article 8.3 is implemented by the Member states.
The organisations responsible for PPDR are convinced that their needs for mission critical broadband services can only be met by dedicated harmonised spectrum.
Those needs have been documented within CEPT who have concluded that there is a need for a minimum of 2 x 10 MHz of spectrum for mobile broadband data services with additional spectrum required when implementing voice services, Air Ground Air, Direct Mode Operation and ad hoc networks.
Public Protection and Disaster Relief is of vital importance to our communities and the emergency services are mandated by law to deliver the highest possible quality of service to society. Whilst saving lives and protecting property, PPDR staff work in very dangerous situations and Governments have the responsibility of ensuring that they have the best possible tools to do their jobs.
It should be noted that RSPP Article 8.3 states: “The Commission shall, in cooperation with the Member States seek to ensure that sufficient spectrum is made available under harmonised conditions to support the development of safety services and the free circulation of related devices as well as the development of innovative interoperable solutions for public safety and protection, civil protection and disaster relief.”
The public safety community needs your help - “Spectrum saves lives”.
How to source a Mission Critical Service
The purpose of this paper is to assist service providers in their understanding of what mission critical service is and what specific legal frameworks are being used today by governments to ensure that the service is always available. Mission Critical operations are being conducted by Public Protection and Disaster Relief (PPDR) organisations including Police, Fire, Rescue and Health organisations.
The TETRA + Critical Communications Association is the sector association representing the interests of over 160 public and private users, operators and manufacturers of mission critical communication services, hardware and software in Europe.
1 DECISION No 243/2012/EU OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 14 March 2012
For more information visit: